Not a conspiracy theory but a true conspiracy:Bombshelll Presentation Reveals Identities Of Maricopa County Election Employees Who Deleted Files From Election Server BEFORE Maricopa County Audit

By Jordan Conradson


We The People AZ Alliance hosted an election security forum in Maricopa County on Saturday, featuring testimony from expert witnesses and state legislators.

This informational hearing, moderated by investigative journalist Lara Logan, presented evidence of fraud in the 2020 Presidential Election and addressed the concerns in the 2022 elections.

The hearing also featured a bombshell testimony revealing exactly who in Maricopa County deleted subpoenaed 2020 Election files before delivery to Arizona Senate auditors. The County was clearly hiding something.

As we reported earlier, Lara dropped a bomb on stage, revealing that the Biden regime is now giving social security numbers to illegals at the border.

Election investigator Matt Vanbibber also shared his discoveries from the Maricopa County Elections Department’s public footage. He finally revealed the identities of individuals who illegally deleted elections files from the Elections Management Server in April 2021.

This data was deleted before the voting machines were delivered to Senate auditors in compliance with a subpoena.

Federal law requires these files to be kept for 22 months.

Maricopa County officials previously admitted that these files were “deleted” in a Congressional hearing but later walked it back and said that the files were “archived.”

This was one of the many law violations discovered by the Arizona audit and other Maricopa County’s 2020 Election investigations.

The Gateway Pundit previously reported on footage of the individuals deleting the files, but their identities were redacted from the public to maintain confidentiality.

On Saturday, it was revealed by Vanbibber that Maricopa County election Database Administrator Brian Ramirez was granted unauthorized entry to the server room on multiple occasions, and he deleted the files.

Ramirez does not have the required credentials to access the server room. However, Vanbibber discovered that he falsely used the identities of individuals who were authorized access.

Vanbibber matched the server room entry logs to the video footage and found Brian Ramirez using others’ cards to access the room.

Vanbibber: So basically, you have Brian entering the server room, and remember I told you he does not have badge access. We The People actually collected server room logs from Maricopa. So I went through all this video footage and matched it with the logs. What you see is Brian has Passarelli’s card in the server room, and he also has Charles Cooley’s badge as well.

Logan: So, Brian is accessing the server room using the identities and cards of other people.

Maricopa County policies also require two people in the server room whenever someone is using the keyboard video monitor, however, Brian was alone on multiple occasions.

In the photo below, Ramirez is alone in the server room, violating County elections policy. The Gateway Pundit previously reported on this violation by an unidentified individual.

Vanbibber then played the video of Brian Ramirez accessing the server room after he was let in by Assistant Elections Director Kristi Passarelli, at the same time that the server logs were deleted.


Ramirez was also alone in the server room again.

Vanbibber: Here she is letting Brian into the server room at that time, and here he is getting on the console. And then you guys know the rest of the history.


Source:  https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2022/07/breaking-bombshell-presentation-reveals-identities-maricopa-county-elections-employees-deleted-files-election-server-maricopa-county-audit/















BREAKING Court Hearing 7/21:GOP lawsuit wants to stop ballot-counting machines in Arizona

By Howard Fischer Capitol Media Services
  • Apr 25, 2022 Updated Jun 3, 2022
GOP lawsuit wants to stop ballot-counting machines in Arizona

Mark Finchem and Kari Lake confer earlier this year on the House floor. Howard Fischer/Capitol Media Services


PHOENIX — Two Republicans seeking statewide office are asking a federal judge to block the use of machines to tabulate the votes in Arizona in the 2022 election.

[Update 7/18/22 The court will hear this case on July 21,2022 at 9:00 AM. The hearing is scheduled to last 5 hours with two hours for plaintiffs to present their case and three hours for the defense's refutation. It will be covered live on frankspeech.com as breaking news through periodic interruptions to existing programs] - ED]

Gubernatorial hopeful Kari Lake and Mark Finchem, running for secretary of state, contend that the machines are unreliable because they are subject to hacking. And they say that the use of components in computers from other countries makes them vulnerable.

But attorney Andrew Parker who filed the lawsuit on their behalf said there is something even more basic.

He said that the tabulation of votes is an inherently governmental function. Yet by using machines built and programmed by private companies the state has effectively farmed that out.

And what’s worse, Parker said in his filings, is that the technology is kept secret from the public.

“This lack of transparency by electronic voting machine companies has created a ‘black box’ system of voting which lacks credibility and integrity,’’ he wrote in a copy of the lawsuit furnished to Capitol Media Services.

What he wants is a court order to have the 2022 election conducted with paper ballots which would be counted by hand, calling it “the most effective and presently the only secure election method.’’

Neither Lake nor Finchem would agree to be interviewed on the lawsuit.

But Lake, in a Facebook interview with Trump supporter Mike Lindell, said the litigation is the result of what she believes was a stolen 2020 election.

“We know how tragic it was that this election (was) corrupted the way it was here in Arizona,’’ she said. “And we don’t want it to happen again.’’

The lawsuit also cites what Parker said were “irregularities and evidence of illegal vote manipulations’’ in voting systems used in the 2020 election. While most of the incidents were from elsewhere, the list includes claims from the Cyber Ninjas “audit’’ of Maricopa County’s election process about things like software and patch protocols not being followed and missing files.

County officials responded to each of the allegations months ago, saying those findings were in error and proved that Cyber Ninjas, which had never done such a review, clearly did not understand election equipment, procedures or laws.

[Patently false. Dominion algorithms have already been uncovered in Antrim County. MIchigan's lawsuit. In particular the Antrim County Forensics Report revealed fraudulent Dominion results. The judge refused to allow the case to proceed further. - ED]

But Parker also said the lawsuit is not an attempt to undo the 2020 presidential results in Arizona which gave Joe Biden the state’s 11 electoral votes.

“It is only about the future — about upcoming elections that will employ voting machines designed and run by private companies, performing a crucial governmental function, that refuse to disclose their software and system components and subject them to neutral expert evaluation,’’ he wrote. “It raises the profound constitutional issue: Can government avoid its obligation of democratic transparency and accountability by delegating a critical government function to private companies?’’

At the heart of the complaint are the contentions by some, particularly among those like Lake and Finchem who still deny the results of the 2020 election, that it was stolen. While some of the issues involve unproven allegations that forged ballots were inserted into the system, there has been a consistent litany of complaints that the hardware and software used to tally ballots was hacked or, worse, was programmed to produce a win for Biden.

“The parallels between the statistical analysis of Venezuela and this year’s election are astonishing,’’ wrote Cyber Ninjas owner Doug Logan even before being hired by Senate President Karen Fann to review the results. That refers to claims that there was a link between Dominion Voting System and the family of now-deceased dictator Hugo Chavez.

“I’m ashamed how few Republicans are talking about it,’’ Logan said.

Parker makes no such claims. Instead he wants a judge to prohibit the use of electronic voting machines in Arizona “unless and until the electronic voting system is made open to the public and subjected to scientific analysis by objective experts to determine whether it is secure from manipulation or intrusion.’’

Arizona does have various systems designed to check equipment.

For example, counties are required to conduct “logic and accuracy’’ tests, both before and after the official tally. That process, done in public, involves taking a known set of ballots and running them through the tallying equipment to ensure that the results reported by the machines matches what actually has been marked.

Parker contends those tests don’t prove anything to deal with what he said are “security problems inherent in the use of electronic voting machines.’’

“All post-election audit procedures can be defeated by sophisticated manipulation of electronic voting machines,’’ he claims.

He specifically cited the refusal of Dominion to surrender its passwords to Cyber Ninjas for examination, with Dominion attorneys saying granting such access to the workings of its equipment violated the company’s protections against illegal search and seizure.

But what Parker does not mention is that there was an agreement between the Senate and the county that allowed three independent experts, including one recommended by the Senate, to examine the equipment. They reported that the system was not connected to the internet and that there was no evidence of data deletion, data purging, data overwriting or other destruction of evidence.

In seeking a court order, Parker wants more than just the use of paper ballots in 2022.

He also wants each ballot to have a unique identification number known only to the voter so each can tell if his or her ballot was counted properly. And Parker said each ballot would be printed on specialized paper that cannot be counterfeited.

The Republican-controlled legislature actually mandated the use of “anti-fraud ballot paper’’ in 2021. But it was voided by the Arizona Supreme Court which ruled that the provision was placed illegally into unrelated budget legislation.

A similar measure was introduced this year but has not been approved.

While the issue of voting machines has largely been a Republican talking point, the lawsuit does have at least one indication of bipartisanship: attorney Alan Dershowitz is part of the legal team.

“You have to understand I’m a liberal Democrat,’’ he said during the Lindell Facebook interview.

“I’m happy with the results of the election,’’ Dershowitz said. “This is about whether or not votes are being properly counted.’’


BREAKING: Arizona Attorney General Releases Maricopa County 2020 Election Interim Report – Individuals To Be Prosecuted For Election Fraud

by Assistant Editor


The Arizona Attorney General has finally released an interim report on his investigation into the Maricopa County November 3rd, 2020 General Election.

The entire investigation has been delayed by Maricopa County’s ‘document preservation & production issues.’ The Attorney General reported to Arizona Senate President Karen Fann that his office is still receiving new information and that Maricopa County has still not fully complied with document requests.

This is similar to noncompliance issues faced by the Arizona Senate and Cyber Ninjas while conducting the full forensic audit of Maricopa County’s 2020 election.

What have they been hiding? 

The letter to Karen Fann said, “The EIU’s review has uncovered instances of election fraud by individuals who have been or will be prosecuted for various elections crimes.”

Mark Brnovich tweeted, “We can report that there are problematic system-wide issues that relate to early ballot handling and verification.”

I just dropped off our initial review of the 2020 election audit to President Fann.

We can report that there are problematic system-wide issues that relate to early ballot handling and verification. https://t.co/Pgogo9A7uO

— Mark Brnovich (@GeneralBrnovich) April 6, 2022

The report reveals that “between 100,000 and 200,000 ballots were transported without a proper chain of custody,” and signature verification standards were greatly decreased in the 2020 election. The Attorney General concluded that “Maricopa County failed to follow the EPM procedures when transporting 20% of the early ballots from drop box locations to MCTEC.”

The Attorney General alleges that 381 out of 1,895 Early Voting Ballot Transport Statements were missing required information such as ballot counts, audit signatures, courrier signatures, election department receiver signals, and documentation of security seals.

This is inconsistent with the Verity Vote investigation findings, which used public records requests for all ballot box retrieval and chain of custody forms utilized in Maricopa County during the 2020 General Election. This investigation found that Maricopa County failed to record the number of ballots on 1,514 out of 1,895 unique EVBTS and failed to record signatures on 48 of these documents.

Regarding signature verification standards, the report states, “the early ballot affidavit signature verification system in Arizona, and particularly when applied to Maricopa County, may be insufficient to guard against abuse.”

Under County Recorder Adrian Fontes, Maricopa County saw a massive decrease in the number of ballots rejected due to missing signatures or mismatched signatures. Due to the large volume of mail-in ballots in the 2020 election, the limited training of elections workers, and time restrictions, the AG’s office determined that 206,648 early ballot signatures were verified on November 4, 2020, with an average time of 4.6 seconds per signature.

As The Gateway Pundit reported, Dr. Shiva’s extensive study of Maricopa County’s signature verification standards found an additional 200,000 signature discrepancies. There was no mention of this groundbreaking report.

This report also failed to mention any crimes committed by ballot traffickers and discovered by True The Vote and Dinesh DSouza. DSouza’s upcoming film is set to expose the nationwide operation that was used to steal the 2020 election from President Trump.

Rassmussen Reports noted the AG’s silence on this key election fraud scam.

2020 Election Integrity: Arizona – Brnovich Has Bupkis Counterfeit ballots, ballot trafficking ballrooms & trafficking mules, nope. 6 months of total silence & then technical excuses on records production don't get you into the U.S. Senate.

Thank you for playing, Mark! https://t.co/0Abo7ekVO0 pic.twitter.com/kQQqH2olO6

Cyber Ninjas CEO Says They Were “Threatened,” Threats Flipped Michigan in 2020

by Publius

{This Sept 27th, 2021 Cyber NInja article is presented to demonstrate how the narrative has twisted since it was posted five
months ago. See Citizen Wells at:
https://citizenwells.com/2021/09/08/az-maricopa-county-canvassing-results-report-september-8-2021-173104-lost-votes-96389-ghost-votes-decertify-election-remove-and-arrest-katie-hobbs/.

The evidence of 2020 fraud as presented by Dr. Douglas Frank and others is still residing on Frankspeech.com and continuing to document the steal. The media has filed an FOIA demand for all correspondence on the Cyber Ninjas audit and
judge Hannah redefines the audit for the AZ senate as a 'public document' so that it will be subject to FOIA laws. 

Judge Hannah then penalizes the Cyber Ninjas $50,000 per day for not providing all requested correspondence to the news paper filing the FOIA request: https://www.westernjournal.com/maricopa-county-judge-fining-cyber-ninjas-50000-per-day-says-wants-put-firm-notice/  This is another attempt to convince the public that the Arizona audit found nothing illegal as they fail to mention known criminal actions.

Interestingly enough, the 2020 dominion criminal referrals reported to the AZ DA over 90 days ago still have seen no action. Arizona Election Fraud: 2 Months After They Were Identified Illegally Deleting 2020 Election Records, Three Individuals Remain Unpunished, Unidentified and Uncharged by AG Mark Brnovich So who are the real fraudsters? - ED ]

Recalling threats to Wayne County, Michigan election officials in 2020 who later signed affidavits saying they regretted their key votes to certify, which handed the state to Biden, the CEO of Cyber Ninjas said in an interview that his team was “threatened” before the release of the report. In the same interview, with Gateway Pundit, Ninjas CEO Doug Logan now says that a previous release of the report which recommended de-certification of the AZ election was a “hoax.”

In November 2020, in swing state Michigan, an arrest was made after pictures of dead, naked women were sent to one of the Republican board members in charge of certifying results, threatening his daughter, and other Republican members also reported threats. Michigan plus one other state in contention, Pennsylvania, would have handed the election to Trump.

Below: Detroit News headline, Nov. 23, 2020 (source)

Logan gave no further

Logan gave no further details in the interview of the threats.{Wasn't this enough? - Ed}

Cyber Ninjas Finds 50,000-plus Ballots with Serious Issues, Margin Was 11,000

Among the findings of a long-awaited report by Cyber Ninjas on the 2020 presidential election:

  • Over 50,000 ballots suffer from serious issues, over 23,000 of those being mail-in ballots from voters who had moved prior to the election. Mail-in ballots in AZ must be received by mail. They cannot be picked up at the election department.

     • “Logs appeared to be intentionally rolled over, and all the data in the database related to the 2020 General Election had  been  fully cleared.” {This supports what the Colorado forensic audit by Tina Peters discovered - ED]

• “Ballot images on the EMS were corrupt or missing.”
  • “Files were missing from the Election Management System (EMS) Server.”
  • The audit could not find an identity match on 86,391 people, in federal, state, USPS, or private databases. These are referred to as “ghost” voters.

[Cyber Ninjas AZ Audit Report, Vol. III Details]  {The report states that more ballots were returned than recieved by voters and more duplicates than original voters. A clear indication of fraud. Note that the report is marked 'For Arizona Senate use Only'; it is not intended as a public document by the auditors. - ED]

Below: Voters on whom no identity match could be found, page 56 Cyber Ninjas report (click for larger image)

Election evidence, which is required by federal law to be preserved for 22 months, was “intentionally” destroyed, which would constitute a federal crime punishable by fines and up to a year in jail, under  52 USC 20701. The law covers “all records and papers,” which would include those in electronic format.

In election integrity cases in Alabama and in Arizona, judges have ruled electronic ballot images are “records.”

Numbers of Problem Ballots Do Not Support Stated Conclusion

The margin of victory in AZ was under 11,000 votes. Thus the number of problem ballot is many times greater than what would be required to change the outcome of the election.

Nevertheless, the report’s Executive Summary states:

“What has been found is both encouraging and revealing. On the positive side there were no substantial differences between the hand count of the ballots provided and the official election canvass results for Maricopa County. This is an important finding because the paper ballots are the best evidence of voter intent and there is no reliable evidence that the paper ballots were altered to any material degree.”

Cyber Ninjas does not explain how this conclusion can be reconciled with many tens of thousands of votes with serious issues , and destruction of evidence, when the victory margin was under 11,000 votes.

From table in Cyber Ninjas report

Federal Law Requires Preservation of “Records”

Among the major findings of the report are the destruction of evidence which may show clear criminal intent, including server files, logs, and ballot images. Federal law requires that all “all records and papers,” which would include in electronic format, be preserved for 22 months in federal elections, in 52 USC 20701. Penalties are fines and imprisonment of up to one year. Although intent is not a factor in the law, the report nevertheless concludes:

• “Logs appeared to be intentionally rolled over, and all the data in the database related to the 2020 General Election had been fully cleared.”

• “Ballot images on the EMS were corrupt or missing.”

52 USC 20701 reads in substantial part:

“Every officer of election shall retain and preserve, for a period of twenty-two months from the date of any general, special, or primary election of which candidates for the office of President…all records and papers which come into his possession…requisite to voting in such election…Any officer of election or custodian who willfully fails to comply with this section shall be fined not more than $1,000 or imprisoned not more than one year, or both.”

It would be up to the Arizona Senate to act on the assertion of what would constitute the federal crime of destruction of election evidence, as well to demand explanation of any conclusions not supported by the ballot data.


{Nonsense! There is more than enough anomolies from the Cyber Ninjas AZ Audit Report, Vol. III Details to decertify the election. Why hasn't that begun? - Ed]