by Ed Condon
Washington D.C., Dec 21, 2018 / 02:00 pm (CNA
A judicial nominee faced questions from Senators this month about
whether membership in the Knights of Columbus might impede his ability
to judge federal cases fairly. The Knights of Columbus say that no
candidate for public office should have to defend his membership in a
Catholic service organization.
Senators Mazie Hirono (D-HI) and Kamala Harris (D-CA) raised concerns
about membership in the Knights of Columbus while the Senate Judiciary
Committee reviewed the candidacy of Brian C. Buescher, an Omaha-based
lawyer nominated by President Trump to sit on the United States District
Court for the District of Nebraska.
Senators also asked whether belonging to the Catholic charitable
organization could prevent judges from hearing cases “fairly and
In written questions
sent to Buescher by committee members Dec. 5, Sen. Hirono stated that
“the Knights of Columbus has taken a number of extreme positions. For
example, it was reportedly one of the top contributors to California’s
Proposition 8 campaign to ban same-sex marriage.”
Hirono then asked Buescher if he would quit the group if he was confirmed “to avoid any appearance of bias.”
“The Knights of Columbus does not have the authority to take personal
political positions on behalf of all of its approximately two million
members,” Buescher responded.
“If confirmed, I will apply all provisions of the Code of Conduct for
United States Judges regarding recusal and disqualification,” he said.
Kathleen Blomquist, spokesperson for the Knights of Columbus, told
CNA that the senators’ questions echoed the kind of anti-Catholicism
seen in previous generations of American history.
“Our country’s sad history of anti-Catholic bigotry contributed to
the founding of the Knights of Columbus, and we are proud of the many
Catholics who overcame this hurdle to contribute so greatly to our
country,” Blomquist told CNA
“We were extremely disappointed to see that one’s commitment to
Catholic principles through membership in the Knights of Columbus—a
charitable organization that adheres to and promotes Catholic
teachings—would be viewed as a disqualifier from public service in this
day and age.”
President Trump nominated Buescher to serve on the U.S. District
Court on Nov. 3. The Senate Judiciary Committee held a hearing on
Buescher’s nomination Nov. 28, sending written questions to him on Dec.
The Knights of Columbus is active in 17 countries worldwide. In 2017,
members carried out more than 75 million hours of volunteer work and
raised more than $185 million for charitable purposes. Successive popes,
including Pope Francis, have praisied the group for their charitable
work and the manner in which they articulate Catholic faith and values.
In her questions to the nominee, Sen. Harris described the Knights as
“an all-male society” and asked if Buescher was aware that the Knights
of Columbus “opposed a woman’s right to choose” and were against
“marriage equality” when he joined.
Responding to the senator’s questions, Buescher confirmed that he has
been a member of the Knights since he was 18 years old, noting that his
membership “has involved participation in charitable and community
events in local Catholic parishes.”
“I do not recall if I was aware whether the Knights of Columbus had
taken a position on the abortion issue when I joined at the age of 18,”
he wrote in response.
Harris raised a statement from Supreme Knight Carl A. Anderson, who
said that abortion constituted “the killing of the innocent on a massive
scale” and asked Buescher if he agreed with Anderson.
Buescher said he was not responsible for drafting statements or
policies made by the Knights and that, as a federal judge, he would
consider himself bound by judicial precedent regarding abortion.
“I did not draft this language. If confirmed, I would be bound by
precedent of the United States Supreme Court and the Eighth Circuit
Court of Appeals and would not be guided by statements made by others,”
Buescher told the senator.
Blomquist told CNA that asking a judicial nominee to defend his
membership of a major Catholic charitable organization is disturbing.
“We believe that membership in the Knights of Columbus, which helps
everyday men put their Catholic faith into action, is worthy of
commendation and not something a nominee for public office should be
asked to defend," she said.
In 2014, Buescher ran as a candidate in the Republican primary
election for Nebraska attorney general. During that campaign he
described himself as “avidly pro-life” and said that opposition to
abortion was part of his “moral fabric.”
Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) noted the nominee’s previously outspoken
opposition to abortion and asked “why should a litigant in your
courtroom expect to get a fair hearing from an impartial judge in a case
involving abortion rights?”
Buescher responded that “as a candidate for Nebraska Attorney General
in 2014, I did what candidates for any major state or federal office
do, which is to take political positions on a variety of issues of the
“However, there is a difference between taking political positions as
a candidate for elective office and serving as a federal judge. I
believe a judge’s role and obligation is to apply the law without regard
to any personal beliefs regarding the law,” Buescher wrote.
“If confirmed, I will faithfully apply all United States Supreme
Court and Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals precedent on all issues,
including Roe v. Wade."
Buescher also fielded questions from senators about Trump
administration policy on Title X funding for clinics providing abortions
and referrals, as well as on the application of anti-discrimination law
to questions related to gender identity or sexual orientation.
The nominee underscored that, as a judge, it was not for him to
advance personal or political opinions but to make fair and impartial
rulings based on the law and judicial precedent.
If confirmed by the Senate, Buescher will fill the vacancy left by
Judge Laurie Smith Camp, who assumed senior status - a kind of judicial
semi-retirement - on Dec. 1.
This story has been updated.